Welcome back to The Studying Speechy!

Today, we are unpacking a crucial piece of literature by Maas et al. (2008) titled “Principles of Motor Learning in Treatment of Motor Speech Disorders”. When working with clients who have motor speech disorders (MSDs) like apraxia of speech or dysarthria, our ultimate goal is to help them establish new motor routines or re-establish old ones.
Because the human brain remains plastic even in adulthood, behavioral treatments can actively promote brain reorganisation and plasticity. But how we structure our therapy sessions matters just as much as what we are practicing! Let’s dive into the Principles of Motor Learning (PML) and how they can revolutionize our clinical practice.
The Big Difference: Performance vs. True Learning
First, we have to change how we measure success. As clinicians, it is easy to be misled by a client’s performance during a therapy session. However, temporary improvements during practice do not necessarily equal true learning.
True motor learning is defined as a relatively permanent change in a person’s capability for movement. To know if learning has actually occurred, we must measure retention (performance after practice has ended) and transfer (generalisation to untrained movements or contexts). The golden rule of motor learning: performance changes during practice do not predict true retention or transfer.
Structuring Your Practice for Maximum Impact
How you organise your practice trials can either make or break long-term learning. Here is what the research says:
Amount and Distribution
- Practice Amount: Generally, a large number of practice trials provides more opportunities to establish reliable motor patterns and automatise movements.
- Practice Distribution: Instead of cramming all practice into a short period (massed practice), distributing practice over a longer period of time facilitates better immediate performance and long-term retention.
Variability and Schedule
- Practice Variability: Drilling the exact same movement constantly (constant practice) might look good in the clinic, but it can result in highly specific skills with limited transfer. Variable practice where you target different variants of a movement, often leads to better long-term retention and transfer because it helps the brain create a more reliable motor schema.
- Practice Schedule:

This is a game-changer! While practicing a group of the exact same targets in a row (blocked practice) enhances performance during practice, intermixing different targets unpredictably (random practice) has a clear advantage for retention and transfer. Random practice forces the client to repeatedly retrieve and construct the motor response from scratch on every single trial.
Target Complexity: The Simple vs. Complex Debate
Traditionally, SLPs are taught to start simple and progress to more complex targets. However, emerging evidence suggests that targeting more complex items early on (like consonant clusters) might actually facilitate transfer to simpler, related behaviors (like singletons). By adequately challenging the learner, we may maximise their learning potential and make our therapy much more efficient.
Rethinking Feedback: Less is More
We are therapists, we love giving feedback! But the motor learning literature tells us we might need to dial it back to foster true independence.

Feedback Frequency
Frequent feedback can actually have negative effects because the learner becomes dependent on the clinician’s guidance. Providing feedback on a low-frequency schedule (for example, only on 60% of trials) prevents this reliance and helps the client develop their own internal error-detection and correction mechanisms.
Feedback Timing
Do you correct a client the exact second they make a mistake? You might want to wait! Providing feedback immediately can actually block the client’s ability to process their own intrinsic feedback. Delaying your feedback for a few seconds allows the client to spontaneously evaluate their own movement before you step in to offer your evaluation.
The Speechy Takeaway
Applying the Principles of Motor Learning requires us to step out of our comfort zones. It means accepting that our clients might make more errors during the actual session (like when using random practice or delayed feedback) in order to achieve the ultimate goal: long-lasting, permanent changes to their speech capability.
Reference:
Maas, E., Robin, D. A., Austermann Hula, S. N., Freedman, S. E., Wulf, G., Ballard, K. J., & Schmidt, R. A. (2008). Principles of motor learning in treatment of motor speech disorders. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 17, 277–298. https://doi.org/10.1044/1058-0360(2008/025
Which of these motor learning principles are you going to try in your next session? Let me know in the comments below!

Leave a Reply